Fighting for 

YOUR FISHING RIGHTS and

THE FUTURE OF RECREATIONAL FISHING

Home Shark Tank Issues SPONSORS FRA TV JOIN THE FRA GIFT Membership FRA GEAR FRA NEWS SA Council Agency Structure Agency Info Member Renewal contact FRACALL TO ACTION!

GULF COUNCIL SECTOR SEPARATION WORKSHOP in TAMPA

CLICK TO WATCH THE FRA's RECORDINGS OF ALL SESSIONS

SPONSOR  LINKS

 

Billy Howell Ford

 

 

PROFESSIONAL

VIDEO

SERVICES

 

 

Jan. 19, 2011- Report on Tampa sector separation workshop is available.  click here for the pdf

 

We are unimpressed with the report and its conclusions.  Read it for yourself.  Note the lack of authorship.  Not sure why it took so long to produce this report.  Were approvals required from EDF people including Whitney Tome?.

 

Watch the FRA video report on the workshop below.

After watching the video, scroll down to read about actions you can take.

Not sure about what the sector separation deal is all about?  You can watch a 30 minute video to learn about the concept.  You will see several documents below that video which make for some interesting reading.

 

Sorry for the commercial!  

We use a free service.

Want to advertise with us?

email us at info@joinFRA.org

 

SPONSOR  LINKS

 

Billy Howell Ford

 

 

PROFESSIONAL

VIDEO

SERVICES

 

 

SPONSOR  LINKS

 

Billy Howell Ford

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

PROFESSIONAL

VIDEO

SERVICES

 

 

 

 

Billy Howell Ford

 

 

PROFESSIONAL

VIDEO

SERVICES

 

 

 

 

Billy Howell Ford

 

 

PROFESSIONAL

VIDEO

SERVICES

 

 

 

What can you do?

 It is time to stop the theft of our fisheries.

Write a letter to your legislators in your own words. This may be a bit intimidating, but it is so important to individually express ideas and concerns. You can also make phone calls to your legislators.  Personal contact is the most effective means of communicating with your elected officials. Get contact information for your congressional representatives, governor and state legislators here.

If you have three or four friends who are willing to sign your letter, it will carry more weight.  Print it, sign  it and mail it to each legislator. Calling the legislators after sending the letter will add weight to your opinion.

If you have any questions about communications, please email us at help@thefra.org


Here are some points to make. Feel free to us a few of these ideas:

Sector separation will cost jobs and economic activity while doing nothing for the health of the fish stocks.

Catch shares have been overwhelmingly rejected for use in the recreational fishery by both the anglers and the managers. Redirect funding from catch shares to recreational data collection.

Federal tax dollars were used to pay an advocacy group to develop a workshop on the very issue that the advocacy group is pushing, all under the guise of transparent and unbiased content development. If this workshop was truly objective and unbiased, shouldn’t Gulf Council staff, and they alone, have dictated the agenda? Shouldn’t the agenda have, at a minimum, contained presenters to show viewpoints opposing sector separation? Why was every presenter/invitee a supporter of sector separation?

Constitutional rights are being infringed upon with the prohibition of recording of a public meeting. Gulf Council Executive Director Dr. Steve Bortone attempted to prohibit a member of the media from recording the meeting in any way. This workshop was noticed as an open public meeting and no such restrictions were provided in the notice. The First Amendment guarantees the freedom of the press to record such a meeting. Even after several council members questioned the practical need to prohibit the recording, staff, along with help from an outside environmental group persisted in their attempt to prohibit the recording, but could point to no legal justification for such prohibition. Surprisingly, staff showed absolutely no deference to council. Staff’s conduct appeared to be solely dictated by an outside environmental group. Why did this occur? And shouldn’t the council be concerned about this?

Maguson-Stevens is being violated in several ways. A congressional investigation of the entire National Marine Fisheries Service is needed. The record is clear that NMFS uses Magnuson to justify and require those actions they want to take, yet they completely ignore the express requirements of Magnuson when they want to. They have blown numerous deadlines imposed by Magnuson on many needed issues, yet are always quick to jump the gun in imposing closures by citing requirements of Magnuson.

Why is a federal employee allowed to deny us our constitutional rights? Why did the same employee ask permission of the advocacy group to release public records to the public? Why did the same employee conceal the charitable/advocacy group as the organizer/developer of the workshop? Why did that same staff member specifically start out the meeting saying that “if one’s mind is made up on sector separation, then this workshop isn’t for you”, only to see that every invited participant had already made up their mind to support sector separation?

The users of the resource are uniformly clamoring that we need better data and science, yet the disdain shown by staff to this concern was palpable throughout the room as the anglers were basically told to get over it and they don’t want to hear about the data any more.

In order to stop this pattern of mismanagement, Dr. Lubchenco should be removed from her position as director of NOAA. It is clear that her involvement with EDF has lead to NOAA’s march to catch shares and the trampling of the recreational angler and commercial fisherman’s constitutional rights.


What will be the direction now? No compelling arguments were presented in support of Sector Separation. Sector separation, if implemented, still requires significant process to follow through and the specific details will be hotly debated. Where is the money and other resources for this going to come from?  What is the justification for spending time and money on this proposal? Would this proposal be on the table if the $52 million for catch shares was not available?

 

WRITE THOSE LETTERS AND MAKE THOSE PHONE CALLS

 

         JUST IN: EDF Lobbyist plan reveals truth about catch shares and sector separation-

“It was originally recommended that sector separation, or separating the for-hire sector from private anglers, should either occur before development of the [catch share] program begins or in step 2."  Click here to read more. 

 

EVERY RECREATIONAL ANGLER HAS A DOG IN THIS FIGHT

Sector separation workshop- justifying the theft of the recreational fishery.

This will set a precedent for ALL areas (South Atlantic, Mid Atlantic, Pacific)

 

FRA CALL TO ACTION

 

When

Monday November 8, noon to 6

4-6 IS THE TIME WE NEED A LARGE TURNOUT

Tuesday November 9, 8:30 to 5, reception 5:30 to 7

Wednesday November 10, 8:30 to noon

 

Where

Crowne Plaza Hotel
5303 West Kennedy Boulevard
Tampa, FL 33607

(813) 289-1950

 

What action should I take?

     Show up at the workshop.  Preferably Monday afternoon.  Also try to make the ‘reception’ on Tuesday night.  We need people that can be at the meetings during Tuesday and Wednesday.  Even if you can only come for a few hours, your presence will be felt and your eyes will be open.  Bring a camera.

Grab an FRA badge (to be available at the meeting).  Click here for the full agenda.

 

JOIN US FOR AN ONLINE SEMINAR ON SUNDAY NIGHT, 8pm

     Dennis O’Hern of the FRA will provide explanation and commentary on the meeting.  Documents will be available for download during the seminar.  We will send further information regarding the seminar’s webpage and password this Friday evening.

 

Why?

    There's a squeeze play going on. Call it a 'rock and a hard place' or just being in between two opposing forces, but we're being squeezed. As recreational anglers, we're facing a threat so profound it could change the sport forever; and so few people are aware of what's going on that we need all the help we can get. We need voices and ears to listen.

 

     The issue is known as Sector Separation. There's a workshop we'll be involved with this month on the 8th. The Gulf Council is providing the 'workshop' to allow differing sides a way to discuss sector separation in a fair, unbiased way. We guess that's why they hired the Environmental Defense Fund to be the host in Tampa with the blessing of the Gulf Council’s Executive Director.  The entire workshop was developed behind closed doors.  Inquiries about the workshop were unanswered or answered with lies.  The Council staff has shown extreme animosity towards the recreational angler, continuing its thwarting of public input. 

NOW is the time for YOU to stand up and be counted.

 

     The sketchy agenda was assembled without any input from the public or any anglers. A small group of charter operators, spurred on by Environmental Defense Fund’s (EDF) push for catch shares in the recreational fishery, claim that the private recreational angler is out of control, using this argument as a basis for keeping the proposed quotas to themselves and renting it back to the recreational angler.  The plan would exclude most of the charter captains in the Gulf from participating.  Greed is rampant in this plan.

 

     Most of the charter captains throughout the Gulf oppose this idea of sector separation. These captains realize that their customers are recreational anglers. Why does this bad idea keep marching? There is some big money behind this bad idea. The Environmental Defense Fund EDF is financing this move, at the bidding of some large institutional investors, including Walmart. Do some research on this socialist group, and realize that if we begin losing more and more of these battles, what we're losing isn't just our right to fish. It's our right to be Americans.

 

     To let you know what we're facing, the EDF put on a special workshop in Jackson Hole, Wyoming two weeks ago to prepare their legion of advocates for this upcoming meeting. What in God's name is so interesting about Wyoming that environmentalists intent on changing our lives don't want to spend their money here?

 

The big picture-

 

     You shouldn't have to have a degree from Harvard to have seen the Green movement generate billions in profits for global concerns. While keeping the planet healthy is something any human being is responsible to do, turning it into a global industry wasn't done by accident. And it's exactly what's happening here.

 

     Using the shroud of environmentalism, the George Soros' of the world can gamble on closing the fisheries for a couple years in order to squeeze out EVERYONE. This eventually drives the dollar-value of catch shares to zero. Once the shares are worthless, investors step in, buy them out, and , we predict, then fund the scientists to find that the fish have miraculously recovered.  By then, you and I will have no real chance to retain a fish that we catch.

 

     The captains that are buying into this are desperate. The economy, the Deep Water Horizon, and just being down-and-out has made our brothers and sisters in our beloved sport easy to mislead. Under the promise of income and special treatment, the people behind the SOS initiative are just using them at the expense of the recreational angler.

 

     What can YOU do about this? Show up and be counted in Tampa during the sector separation workshop.  Scheduled from noon Monday, November 8th  to noon Wednesday, November 10th, this ‘workshop’ is the work of EDF.  Can you make any of the workshop? Please email us at FRA@tampabay.rr.com if you plan to attend.

 

     We need several people to attend full time, as well as a HUGE turnout Monday afternoon. You don’t need to speak. Just BE THERE and BE COUNTED. You will have the opportunity to meet some of the people who want to take your fish. Let them know with your presence that you will not be a victim of theft.  Bring a camera.

 

     If you can’t make the start of the meeting Monday, you should still make every attempt to show up Monday afternoon at some point during the meeting, even if it is 4 or 4:30. This is going to be a critical time for you to be counted.  ‘Public input’ for what it is worth, is scheduled for 4:30 to 6 PM this day only.

 

     The meeting will include several breakout sessions (divide and conquer?) which will require a solid presence of charter captains and recreational anglers. See the agenda

 

     The Gulf Council is requesting that you send them an email if you plan to participate.  It is not a requirement, as we understand.  gulfcouncil@gulfcouncil.org  They are only providing seating for about a hundred in the audience.  We expect many times that to show up.

MEETING LOCATION

 

Crowne Plaza

5303 W Kennedy Blvd

Tampa, FL

813-289-1950

 

click on map

 

----------------------------

 

Post Meeting Gathering

 

Players Sports Pub

in the

DOUBLETREE HOTEL

4500 West Cypress

Tampa, FL

click on map

 

LINKS

FRA Broadcast Page

Watch the 'workshop'

 Who is trying to steal YOUR fish?

 

Get the pdf

 FRA workshop flyer

 
 

 

 

 

EDF Lobbyist plan reveals truth about catch shares and sector separation

 

This just in from Captain Bob Zales, a NATIONAL LEADER of charter captains.  Spread this around, post it up and let the light shine on the truth.

It is time to TERMINATE LUBCHENCO.  Tired of the Jane-pain?

YOU MUST SHOW UP ON MONDAY, EVEN IF IT IS ONLY FROM 4-6 PM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

From Captain Zales:

 

For those who have heard over and over from the SOS’ers that sector separation has nothing to do with catch shares, please read the below statements copied direct from the:

 

Considerations for design of a catch share manual for the recreational for-hire sector

Prepared by MRAG Americas, October 2010”. 

 

This document was prepared by MRAG because the EDF Lobbyists paid them to create a for-hire sector catch share manual.  They had a meeting in Boston last March and most recently the secret meeting in Jackson Hole, WY where, according to Heather Paffe regional director for the gulf of mexico and southeast-EDF Oceans, “Last week EDF hosted a collaborative workshop with for-hire (charter) fishermen from across the country (the charter captain [one] from the Gulf was Mike Jennings the TX SOS chairman, Rick Bellavance from Rhode Island, John Blair, Gregg Sutter, and Tom Ohaus from AK, total of 5 charter captains from 3 geographic areas)”.

Now, I don’t know about any of you but 5 charterboat fishermen do not seem to be representative of “across the county” especially when there were only 3 states represented out of 23 coastal states. 

 

“It was originally recommended that sector separation, or separating the for-hire sector from private anglers, should either occur before development of the program begins or in step 2. With sector separation at the beginning of the process, fishermen can take control and responsibility of their own sector and be involved in the development of the catch share program. However, depending on the political climate, it may not be possible to achieve sector separation at the outset of a program, and it will be necessary to work towards it and fit it into the process wherever possible.”

 

Now, if what those who represent SOS say is true (and we always heard they are all about honesty, truth, and facts), then the EDF Lobbyists have clearly lied to them because those who represent SOS still say that sector separation has nothing to do with catch shares.  Now is the time for them to stand up and publically question why the EDF Lobbyists have lied to them OR come clean with their agenda for the for-hire charterboats.  It is really very simple.

 

Capt Bob Zales, II